CheckMySize research · data from 2026-11-15
Which shoe brands run small or large?
Size charts say what a brand should fit like. We looked at what people actually buy: 8,160 comparisons from CheckMySize users who own two or more brands. If owners of a brand usually pick a bigger number in it than in their other shoes, it runs small. If they pick a smaller number, it runs large.
Key findings
- Tend to run small: men Reebok, Puma, Yeezy, Vans; women Skechers, Reebok, Vans, Asics.
- Tend to run large: men Red Wing, Birkenstock, Timberland, Converse, Crocs; women Adidas, Dr. Martens, Birkenstock, Salomon.
- For men, the big sneaker brands (Nike, Adidas, New Balance, Asics) are within a quarter size of each other.
Men's shoes: brand fit ranking
- Reebok+0.24
- Puma+0.22
- Yeezy+0.19
- Vans+0.15
- Hoka+0.07
- Nike+0.07
- Nike SB+0.07
- New Balance+0.06
- Asics+0.03
- Adidas+0.02
- Salomon+0.02
- Brooks±0.00
- Mizuno±0.00
- On±0.00
- Onitsuka Tiger±0.00
- Saucony±0.00
- Jordan−0.03
- Dr. Martens−0.06
- Clarks−0.44
- Crocs−0.45
- Converse−0.49
- Timberland−0.55
- Birkenstock−0.60
- Red Wing−0.62
Show men's table
| Brand | Fit | What to do | Avg. difference (US) | Owners compared |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Reebok | runs slightly small | Half a size up if you're between sizes | +0.24 | 175 |
| Puma | runs slightly small | Half a size up if you're between sizes | +0.22 | 296 |
| Yeezy | runs slightly small | Half a size up if you're between sizes | +0.19 | 127 |
| Vans | runs slightly small | Half a size up if you're between sizes | +0.15 | 621 |
| Hoka | true to size | Take your usual size | +0.07 | 280 |
| Nike | true to size | Take your usual size | +0.07 | 2,464 |
| Nike SB | true to size | Take your usual size | +0.07 | 67 |
| New Balance | true to size | Take your usual size | +0.06 | 1,343 |
| Asics | true to size | Take your usual size | +0.03 | 948 |
| Adidas | true to size | Take your usual size | +0.02 | 1,893 |
| Salomon | true to size | Take your usual size | +0.02 | 246 |
| Brooks | true to size | Take your usual size | ±0.00 | 173 |
| Mizuno | true to size | Take your usual size | ±0.00 | 56 |
| On | true to size | Take your usual size | ±0.00 | 89 |
| Onitsuka Tiger | true to size | Take your usual size | ±0.00 | 56 |
| Saucony | true to size | Take your usual size | ±0.00 | 225 |
| Jordan | true to size | Take your usual size | −0.03 | 472 |
| Dr. Martens | true to size | Take your usual size | −0.06 | 210 |
| Clarks | runs large | Consider half a size down | −0.44 | 86 |
| Crocs | runs large | Consider half a size down | −0.45 | 71 |
| Converse | runs large | Consider half a size down | −0.49 | 505 |
| Timberland | runs large | Consider half a size down | −0.55 | 117 |
| Birkenstock | runs large | Consider half a size down | −0.60 | 203 |
| Red Wing | runs large | Consider half a size down | −0.62 | 65 |
Women's shoes: brand fit ranking
- Skechers+0.56
- Reebok+0.32
- Vans+0.30
- Asics+0.21
- New Balance+0.19
- Nike+0.19
- On+0.19
- Puma+0.13
- Crocs+0.08
- UGG+0.07
- Converse+0.06
- Hoka−0.06
- Salomon−0.25
- Birkenstock−0.33
- Dr. Martens−0.38
- Adidas−0.42
Show women's table
| Brand | Fit | What to do | Avg. difference (US) | Owners compared |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Skechers | runs small | Consider half a size up | +0.56 | 115 |
| Reebok | runs slightly small | Half a size up if you're between sizes | +0.32 | 107 |
| Vans | runs slightly small | Half a size up if you're between sizes | +0.30 | 410 |
| Asics | runs slightly small | Half a size up if you're between sizes | +0.21 | 274 |
| New Balance | runs slightly small | Half a size up if you're between sizes | +0.19 | 547 |
| Nike | runs slightly small | Half a size up if you're between sizes | +0.19 | 924 |
| On | runs slightly small | Half a size up if you're between sizes | +0.19 | 59 |
| Puma | true to size | Take your usual size | +0.13 | 166 |
| Crocs | true to size | Take your usual size | +0.08 | 128 |
| UGG | true to size | Take your usual size | +0.07 | 84 |
| Converse | true to size | Take your usual size | +0.06 | 594 |
| Hoka | true to size | Take your usual size | −0.06 | 169 |
| Salomon | runs slightly large | Half a size down if you're between sizes | −0.25 | 69 |
| Birkenstock | runs slightly large | Half a size down if you're between sizes | −0.33 | 395 |
| Dr. Martens | runs large | Consider half a size down | −0.38 | 430 |
| Adidas | runs large | Consider half a size down | −0.42 | 827 |
How we measured it
- CheckMySize users enter the brands and sizes they own and how each pair fits. Sizes marked too big or too small are adjusted by half a size.
- For every pair of brands, we take the people who own both and measure the average difference between their sizes (in UK sizes, as each brand labels them). Outliers and inconsistent profiles are removed.
- For each brand, we convert sizes from every other brand it is compared with (men US 7–12, women US 6–10) using those averages and each brand's official size chart, and measure the difference in US size.
- We average those differences, weighted by how many people own both brands. Brands need at least 10 owners per comparison, 3 other brands and 50 owners in total to be included.
Fit can differ between models of the same brand, and the result is relative to the brands our users own (mostly popular sneaker brands). For your exact size, use the free tool with all the shoes you own.
You are welcome to use these findings. Please credit and link to CheckMySize (checkmysize.com/research/shoe-brands-that-run-small).
Find your size
Check your size with all your shoes →
Or compare two brands directly: all size comparisons.